Local Prepositions Answering Woher? (Lokale Präpositionen mit Woher?)
CEFR level A2 · Chapter 39 · 79 exercises · about 22 minutes
Choose correctly between aus and von to say where someone or something comes from, apply the vom contraction, and connect the woher? pattern to the wohin? and wo? prepositions already learned so that destination, location, and origin form one consistent system.
Practise Local Prepositions Answering Woher?
Woher? asks about origin: where does someone or something come from? You already know how to say where something is going (wohin?, Chapter 37, with prepositions such as in and zu) and where something currently is (wo?, Chapter 38, with prepositions such as in and bei). This chapter adds the third piece of the puzzle: the prepositions that answer woher?, above all aus and von.
The good news is that you are not learning a new system from scratch. The prepositions you already know for destination and location line up with aus and von in two clear patterns: enclosed places and countries use in / in / aus, while people and institutions such as the doctor use zu / bei / von. Once you see the pattern, choosing the right preposition for origin becomes far more predictable.
Woher? and the dative case
Woher? means "from where?" and is answered with a prepositional phrase that names the place, country, or person something comes from. Both prepositions used for origin in this chapter, aus and von, always take the dative case, no matter which article or noun follows.
Ich komme aus der Schweiz. (I am from Switzerland.) — der Schweiz is dative feminine. Ich komme von meiner Freundin. (I am coming from my girlfriend's place.) — meiner Freundin is dative feminine. The case is fixed; the only real decision is which preposition, aus or von, fits the situation.
aus: out of an enclosed place, a country, or an origin
Use aus when something comes out of an enclosed space — a room, a building, a container — or out of a country, since a country is treated the same way a building is: as a space you can be inside of and then leave. Ich komme aus dem Büro. (I am coming from the office.) Wir kommen aus dem Kino. (We are coming out of the cinema.)
aus is also the preposition for stating where someone is originally from, including nationality and hometown: Ich komme aus Deutschland. (I am from Germany.) Sie kommt aus Berlin. (She is from Berlin.) Most country and city names take aus with no article at all; a few countries that do have an article, like die Schweiz or die USA, still take aus, simply with the article added: aus der Schweiz, aus den USA.
von: from a person, an open place, or a starting point
Use von when the origin is a person rather than a place: Ich komme von meiner Freundin. (I am coming from my girlfriend's.) Er kommt von seinem Bruder. (He is coming from his brother's.) A person is never treated as a container, so aus is never used for people.
von is also used for open places, events, and general starting points that are not thought of as enclosed spaces: Wir kommen von der Arbeit. (We are coming from work.) Er kommt von der Party. (He is coming from the party.) Ich komme von zu Hause. (I am coming from home.)
When von is followed by the masculine or neuter dative article dem, the two words contract to vom: von + dem Bahnhof becomes vom Bahnhof (from the train station); von + dem Arzt becomes vom Arzt (from the doctor's). The feminine dative article der does not contract: von der Arbeit stays as two words.
Pattern one: enclosed places and countries — in / in / aus
For enclosed places and most countries, the three question words you have now learned line up neatly: wohin? uses in with the accusative (Ich gehe ins Büro.), wo? uses in with the dative (Ich bin im Büro.), and woher? uses aus with the dative (Ich komme aus dem Büro.).
The same pattern applies to the cinema, the supermarket, the office, the kitchen, and to countries: Wohin gehst du? — In die Schweiz. Wo bist du? — In der Schweiz. Woher kommst du? — Aus der Schweiz. Learning all three together for the same place makes each one easier to remember.
School and university are flexible: wohin? is usually zur Schule / zur Uni (Chapter 37) or in die Schule, wo? is in der Schule, and woher? can be aus der Schule or von der Schule — both are correct.
Pattern two: people and institutions — zu / bei / von
For people, and for places strongly associated with a person, such as the doctor's or the hairdresser's, a different but equally consistent set applies: wohin? uses zu with the dative (Ich gehe zum Arzt.), wo? uses bei with the dative (Ich bin beim Arzt.), and woher? uses von with the dative (Ich komme vom Arzt.).
Wohin gehst du? — Zu meiner Freundin. Wo bist du? — Bei meiner Freundin. Woher kommst du? — Von meiner Freundin. All three prepositions in this pattern, zu, bei, and von, already take the dative, so no case changes as the question word changes — only the preposition itself changes to fit destination, location, or origin.
Choosing between aus and von
When you are unsure whether to use aus or von, ask first whether the origin is a person or a place. If it is a person, always use von. If it is a place, ask whether that place is best thought of as an enclosed space or a country (use aus) or as an open place, event, or starting point (use von).
A few institutions can feel borderline, but the same logic that applies to wohin? and wo? for that institution also applies to woher?: if you would say ins Büro and im Büro, you say aus dem Büro; if you would say zum Arzt and beim Arzt, you say vom Arzt.
| Type | Wohin? (destination) | Wo? (location) | Woher? (origin) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enclosed place or country | in (+ accusative) | in (+ dative) | aus (+ dative) |
| Person or institution (e.g. the doctor) | zu (+ dative) | bei (+ dative) | von (+ dative) |
The Wohin? column is not tagged with a single case here because it mixes in (+ accusative) for enclosed places with zu (+ dative) for people — the case in that column depends on which row you are in.
| Use aus | Use von |
|---|---|
| Countries and cities: aus Deutschland, aus Berlin | People: von meiner Freundin, von meinem Bruder |
| Enclosed places: aus dem Büro, aus dem Kino | Open places and events: von der Arbeit, von der Party |
| Stating origin/nationality: Ich komme aus Italien. | Starting points: von hier, von zu Hause |
Both aus and von always take the dative case, whichever side of the table you use.
| Full form | Contraction | Example |
|---|---|---|
| von + dem (masculine, dative) | vom | vom Bahnhof (from the train station) |
| von + dem (neuter, dative) | vom | vom Training (from training) |
| von + der (feminine, dative) | no contraction | von der Arbeit (from work) |
Only von + dem contracts to vom; von + der is always written as two words.
Examples
- Woher kommst du? – Ich komme aus Deutschland. — Where are you from? – I am from Germany. Countries are treated as origin points you come out of, so Deutschland takes aus.
- Meine Familie kommt aus der Schweiz. — My family is from Switzerland. die Schweiz has an article but still takes aus, like other countries; the article appears in the dative form der.
- Er kommt gerade aus dem Büro. — He is just coming out of the office. The office is an enclosed place, so leaving it is expressed with aus, matching the pattern ins Büro / im Büro.
- Ich komme gerade von meiner Freundin. — I am just coming from my girlfriend's place. A person as the origin always takes von, never aus.
- Wir kommen von der Arbeit. — We are coming from work. Work is treated as an open starting point rather than an enclosed container, so it takes von.
- Der Zug kommt gerade vom Bahnhof. — The train is just coming from the station. der Bahnhof is masculine, so von + dem contracts to vom.
- Ich gehe zum Arzt, bin dann beim Arzt und komme später vom Arzt. — I am going to the doctor's, then I am at the doctor's, and later I come from the doctor's. The same person, der Arzt, uses zu for destination, bei for location, and von for origin — all three take the dative.
- Sie kommt aus den USA. — She is from the USA. die USA is a plural country name; the dative plural article is den, but the preposition is still aus.
- Wir kommen gerade aus dem Kino. — We are just coming out of the cinema. The cinema is an enclosed building, so aus is used, just as with the office.
- Ich komme gerade von zu Hause. — I am just coming from home. zu Hause (at home) is a fixed expression; the origin form uses von, not aus.
- Er kommt gerade von der Party. — He is just coming from the party. A party is treated as an open event rather than an enclosed space, so it takes von.
- Kommst du aus Berlin oder aus München? — Are you from Berlin or from Munich? City names take aus with no article, just like most country names.
Common mistakes
Ich komme von Deutschland.→ Ich komme aus Deutschland.. Countries take aus, not von, because they are treated as enclosed places of origin, not as people or open starting points.Ich komme aus meiner Freundin.→ Ich komme von meiner Freundin.. A person as the origin always takes von; aus is reserved for enclosed places, countries, and origins of nationality, never for people.Der Zug kommt von dem Bahnhof.→ Der Zug kommt vom Bahnhof.. von + dem contracts to vom in everyday German; leaving the two words uncontracted sounds unnatural in this very common phrase.Ich komme von der Schweiz.→ Ich komme aus der Schweiz.. Countries, including feminine ones like die Schweiz, take aus, not von, following the same rule as all other countries.Ich komme aus dem Arzt.→ Ich komme vom Arzt.. People and person-associated institutions like the doctor follow the zu / bei / von pattern, not the in / in / aus pattern, so the origin preposition is von, contracted to vom.
Remember
- aus is for enclosed places, countries, and stating origin/nationality: aus der Schweiz, aus dem Büro, aus Deutschland.
- von is for people, open places, events, and starting points: von meiner Freundin, von der Arbeit, von der Party.
- von + dem contracts to vom (vom Bahnhof, vom Arzt); von + der never contracts.
- The three question words share the same logic: in / in / aus for enclosed places and countries; zu / bei / von for people and institutions like the doctor.