All chapters

Temporal Clauses with während, bevor, nachdem, and seit (Temporalsätze mit während, bevor, nachdem und seit)

CEFR level B1 · Chapter 78 · 74 exercises · about 30 minutes

Choose correctly among während (while, simultaneous events), bevor (before), nachdem (after, applying the "tense back" rule that pairs past perfect/present perfect with simple past/present), and seit/seitdem (since, an ongoing action normally in the present tense) to link two clauses, and apply correct verb-final word order, comma placement, and inversion in each.

Practise Temporal Clauses with während, bevor, nachdem, and seit

You already know several subordinating conjunctions that send the finite verb to the end of their clause: weil, wenn, and dass (Chapter 46), and nachdem, bevor, and als paired with the past perfect (Chapter 55). This chapter expands your temporal toolkit with a set of connectors that describe how two events in time relate to each other: während (while, at the same time), bevor (before), nachdem (after), and seit/seitdem (since). Each one answers a different question about the relationship between the action in the subordinate clause and the action in the main clause.

während is the simplest of the four: it links two actions happening at the same time, and both clauses are usually in the same tense. bevor and nachdem both describe a sequence of two events, but from opposite directions — bevor names the later event, nachdem names the earlier one. nachdem is the connector that demands the most care, because German grammatically marks the earlier event as already completed relative to the main clause: the nachdem-clause must take a tense one step "further back" than the main clause (past perfect if the main clause is simple past, present perfect if the main clause is present). This chapter treats that "tense back" rule as its central teaching point.

Finally, seit and seitdem (used interchangeably, though seit is far more common) introduce an action that began in the past and is still going on. Unlike English, which uses the present perfect for this ("I have lived here for two years"), German normally uses the present tense: Seit ich hier wohne, fühle ich mich wohler. Mixing this up — reaching for a German present perfect because English uses one — is one of the most persistent mistakes for English speakers, so this chapter gives it special attention alongside the nachdem tense-back rule.

All four are subordinating conjunctions: verb to the end, comma always

während, bevor, nachdem, and seit/seitdem behave exactly like weil, wenn, and dass: they introduce a subordinate clause whose finite verb moves to the very end, and a comma always separates the subordinate clause from the main clause, regardless of which order the two clauses appear in.

Ich lese, während du kochst. / Während du kochst, lese ich. Both orders are grammatical; only the position of the comma and the verb changes, never whether a comma is needed.

während — two actions happening at the same time

während corresponds to English "while" and links two actions that overlap in time. Because both actions are happening simultaneously, both clauses are normally in the same tense: both present, or both simple past.

Während ich kochte, las er die Zeitung. (While I was cooking, he was reading the newspaper — both simple past, both actions running in parallel.) Während ich arbeite, hört meine Schwester Musik. (While I work, my sister listens to music — both present.)

bevor — the subordinate clause names the later event

bevor corresponds to English "before". The bevor-clause always names the event that happens later, chronologically, than the main clause — even though it is grammatically the subordinate clause. Because English "before" does not require any special tense marking, German bevor usually does not either: both clauses typically share the same tense.

Bevor wir aßen, deckten wir den Tisch. (Before we ate, we set the table — setting the table happened first, eating happened second; both clauses are simple past.) Bevor du gehst, ruf mich bitte an. (Before you leave, please call me.)

nachdem — the "tense back" rule (the core rule of this chapter)

nachdem corresponds to English "after". The nachdem-clause always names the earlier event — but unlike bevor, German requires that earlier event to be grammatically marked as already completed relative to the main clause. This means the nachdem-clause must be one tense "further back" than the main clause: if the main clause is in the simple past, the nachdem-clause takes the past perfect; if the main clause is in the present (including describing a habitual or near-future sequence), the nachdem-clause takes the present perfect.

Worked example, past: Nachdem ich gegessen hatte, ging ich spazieren. (After I had eaten, I went for a walk.) The main clause ging is simple past, so the earlier event steps one tense back to the past perfect, gegessen hatte.

Worked example, present: Nachdem ich gegessen habe, gehe ich spazieren. (After I have eaten, I go for a walk.) Here the main clause gehe is present, so the earlier event steps one tense back to the present perfect, gegessen habe — not the plain present esse, and not the past perfect hatte gegessen, which would be one step too far back.

seit / seitdem — an action that started in the past and still continues

seit and seitdem both correspond to English "since" and introduce an action or state that began at some point in the past and is still ongoing now. They are largely interchangeable as conjunctions, though seit is more common in everyday speech. Chapter 33 already introduced seit as a preposition with a dative time expression (seit zwei Jahren); here seit/seitdem instead introduces a whole clause with its own verb.

The key difference from English is the tense: German normally uses the present tense in both clauses for an ongoing situation, where English uses the present perfect. Seit ich hier wohne, fühle ich mich viel wohler. (Since I have been living here, I feel much happier — wohne is present, not a perfect form.) Seitdem sie in Berlin lebt, spricht sie fließend Deutsch. (Since she has been living in Berlin, she speaks German fluently.)

If the seit-clause instead names a single, already-completed event whose result continues (rather than a drawn-out ongoing activity), the present perfect can appear there too: Seit er umgezogen ist, sehen wir uns seltener. (Since he moved, we see each other less often — umgezogen ist reports the one-time move itself.) But for a genuinely ongoing action, the present tense is the default and the form to reach for first.

Clause order and word order recap

Like every subordinate clause, one built with während, bevor, nachdem, or seit/seitdem can come before or after the main clause. When it comes first, it fills position 1 of the whole sentence by itself, so the main clause's finite verb must follow immediately after the comma, before its own subject (inversion) — exactly as with weil and wenn.

Während ich kochte, las er die Zeitung. (las stands right after the comma, before er.) Inside the subordinate clause itself, the verb-final rule still applies within whatever tense is used: for a past-perfect nachdem-clause, the participle comes first and the auxiliary hatte/war closes the clause (gegessen hatte); for a present-perfect one, the participle comes first and habe/bin closes it (gegessen habe).

Connector comparison: während, bevor, nachdem, seit
ConnectorMeaningTypical tense pairingExample
während (while)simultaneous events, happening at the same timesame tense in both clauses (present + present, or simple past + simple past)Während ich kochte, las er die Zeitung.
bevor (before)the bevor-clause names the later eventusually the same tense in both clausesBevor wir aßen, deckten wir den Tisch.
nachdem (after)the nachdem-clause names the earlier eventone tense back: past perfect + simple past, or present perfect + presentNachdem ich gegessen hatte, ging ich spazieren.
seit / seitdem (since)an action that started in the past and continuespresent tense in both clauses (not present perfect, unlike English)Seit ich hier wohne, fühle ich mich wohler.
nachdem: the "tense back" pairing
Main clause tensenachdem-clause tenseExample
simple past (ging)past perfect (gegessen hatte)Nachdem ich gegessen hatte, ging ich spazieren.
present (gehe)present perfect (gegessen habe)Nachdem ich gegessen habe, gehe ich spazieren.
present describing a later step (gehe ... später)present perfect (gegessen habe)Nachdem ich gegessen habe, gehe ich später spazieren.

The nachdem-clause is always exactly one grammatical step "further back" than the main clause — never the same tense, and never two steps back.

Word order: subordinate clause first vs. second
Main clause first (neutral order)Subordinate clause first (inversion)
Er las die Zeitung, während ich kochte.Während ich kochte, las er die Zeitung.
Wir deckten den Tisch, bevor wir aßen.Bevor wir aßen, deckten wir den Tisch.
Ich ging spazieren, nachdem ich gegessen hatte.Nachdem ich gegessen hatte, ging ich spazieren.
Ich fühle mich wohler, seit ich hier wohne.Seit ich hier wohne, fühle ich mich wohler.

Whichever clause opens the sentence fills position 1; the other clause's finite verb then stands immediately after the comma, in position 2.

Examples

Common mistakes

Remember

Practise Temporal Clauses with während, bevor, nachdem, and seit: 74 exercises