Coordinating Conjunctions (Nebenordnende Konjunktionen)
CEFR level A2 · Chapter 44 · 79 exercises · about 25 minutes
Connect two main clauses with und, aber, oder, denn, and sondern without disturbing normal main-clause word order, apply the comma rules for each connector, choose correctly between aber and sondern based on whether the first clause is negated and the second clause replaces it, and drop a repeated subject in the second clause when it is shared and would otherwise begin that clause.
Practise Coordinating Conjunctions
Und (and), aber (but/however), oder (or), denn (because/for), and sondern (but rather) are the five coordinating conjunctions of German. They connect two clauses of equal rank — usually two complete main clauses — without changing the word order inside either clause. Each clause keeps its own normal verb-second order, exactly as if it stood alone.
Because these connectors do not affect word order, the real challenge is choosing the right one and punctuating it correctly. The trickiest pair is aber and sondern: both can be translated as "but", yet only one of them is correct in a given sentence. The choice depends on the conversational context — specifically, on whether the first clause is negated and whether the second clause directly contradicts and replaces it. This is exactly the kind of pragmatic judgment that a short dialogue can make clear where an isolated sentence cannot.
Five connectors, one job: linking two main clauses
Und, aber, oder, denn, and sondern join two clauses that could each stand on their own as a complete sentence. Grammarians say they sit in "position 0": they are not counted as a sentence element and do not take up the first or second position of either clause.
Ich koche das Essen, und du deckst den Tisch. (I am cooking the meal, and you are setting the table.) Both "Ich koche das Essen" and "du deckst den Tisch" are independent main clauses; und simply links them.
Word order stays normal: verb stays in second position
Because a coordinating conjunction does not occupy a position in either clause, the verb in the clause that follows it stays in its usual second position — it is not sent to the end, and the subject and verb are not inverted.
This is the key difference from subordinating connectors like weil or dass (covered in a later chapter), which do send the verb to the end. Denn looks like it introduces a reason the way weil does, but denn is coordinating, so word order after it is completely normal: Wir bleiben zu Hause, denn es regnet. (not "...denn es regnet heute" reordered to "...denn es heute regnet").
Comma rules: always before aber, denn, sondern
Aber, denn, and sondern always take a comma directly before them when they connect two main clauses, with no exceptions.
Und and oder do not require a comma before them when they connect two main clauses, although a comma is allowed there for clarity in longer sentences. When und or oder simply connects two words or phrases rather than two full clauses (e.g. "Brot und Milch"), no comma is used at all.
Sondern only after a negation, to replace it
Sondern can only follow a clause that contains a negation with nicht or kein, and the second clause must name the true alternative that replaces what was just denied. The two halves cannot both be true — sondern corrects the first statement.
Er trinkt keinen Kaffee, sondern Tee. (He does not drink coffee, but rather tea.) The first clause denies coffee; the second clause supplies the fact that actually applies.
Aber vs. sondern: contrast versus correction
Aber can follow either an affirmative or a negative clause and simply adds a contrast; both statements can be true at the same time. Sondern can only follow a negated clause, and the two statements are mutually exclusive — the second one replaces the first.
Compare: Ich mag Tee, aber ich trinke lieber Kaffee. (I like tea, but I prefer to drink coffee — both can be true.) versus Ich trinke keinen Tee, sondern Kaffee. (I do not drink tea, but rather coffee — only one can be true.) A negated first clause does not automatically require sondern: if the second clause merely comments or adds a reason rather than replacing the negated fact, aber or denn is still correct.
Dropping a shared subject
When both clauses share the same subject, the subject can be dropped from the second clause, but only when it would otherwise be the very first word of that clause. Dropping the subject then also merges the two verbs into a shared subject relationship, and no comma is needed before und in that case.
Ich gehe ins Kino und sehe einen Film. (I am going to the cinema and watching a film.) Here "ich" is dropped from the second clause because it would have been the first word.
If another element — such as an adverb — comes first in the second clause, the subject cannot be dropped, because it is no longer in the position right before the verb: Ich gehe heute ins Kino, und danach besuche ich meine Oma. (Today I am going to the cinema, and afterwards I am visiting my grandma.) Here "danach" takes first position, so "ich" must stay and moves after the verb.
| Conjunction | Meaning | Comma before it? | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| und | and | not required (optional) | Ich koche, und du deckst den Tisch. |
| aber | but / however | always required | Ich bin müde, aber ich arbeite weiter. |
| oder | or | not required (optional) | Kommst du mit, oder bleibst du hier? |
| denn | because / for | always required | Wir bleiben zu Hause, denn es regnet. |
| sondern | but rather (after negation) | always required | Er ist nicht müde, sondern hungrig. |
In every case, the verb in the clause after the connector stays in normal second position — none of these five connectors change word order.
| Question | aber | sondern |
|---|---|---|
| Must the first clause be negated? | No — aber can follow an affirmative or a negative clause. | Yes — sondern can only follow a clause negated with nicht or kein. |
| Can both statements be true at once? | Yes — aber simply adds a contrast. | No — sondern means the second clause replaces/corrects the first. |
| Example | Ich mag Tee, aber ich trinke lieber Kaffee. | Ich trinke keinen Tee, sondern Kaffee. |
A negated first clause does not by itself require sondern — check whether the second clause truly replaces the negated fact, or merely adds a separate comment (then aber is still correct).
Examples
- Ich koche das Essen, und du deckst den Tisch. — I am cooking the meal, and you are setting the table. und simply adds a second, parallel action with no contrast.
- Möchtest du Tee oder Kaffee? — Would you like tea or coffee? oder presents two alternatives to choose between.
- Wir bleiben zu Hause, denn es regnet den ganzen Tag. — We are staying home, because it is raining all day. denn introduces a reason and keeps the verb in second position: es regnet.
- Das Hotel ist teuer, aber es lohnt sich. — The hotel is expensive, but it is worth it. aber expresses a simple contrast; nothing is being negated and replaced here.
- Er trinkt keinen Kaffee, sondern Tee. — He does not drink coffee, but rather tea. The first clause is negated (keinen Kaffee), and the second clause replaces it with the true alternative.
- Das ist kein Fehler, sondern eine gute Idee. — That is not a mistake, but rather a good idea. "kein Fehler" is negated, and "eine gute Idee" is the fact that replaces it.
- Ich gehe ins Kino und sehe einen Film. — I am going to the cinema and watching a film. The shared subject ich is dropped from the second clause because it would have been the first word there.
- Ich gehe heute ins Kino, und danach besuche ich meine Oma. — Today I am going to the cinema, and afterwards I am visiting my grandma. danach occupies first position in the second clause, so the shared subject ich cannot be dropped and instead follows the verb.
- Ich kaufe Brot und Milch. — I am buying bread and milk. und here connects two nouns, not two full clauses, so no comma is used.
- Er war nicht besonders spannend, aber die Schauspieler waren gut. — It (the film) was not especially exciting, but the actors were good. The second clause does not replace the claim about excitement — both statements can be true — so this is a contrast with aber, not a correction with sondern.
- Bist du müde, oder kannst du noch weiterarbeiten? — Are you tired, or can you keep working? oder links two complete questions as alternatives; a comma here is optional but allowed for clarity.
- Ich bin noch nicht fertig, denn ich brauche noch etwas Zeit. — I'm not finished yet, because I still need some time. Even though the first clause is negated, the second clause explains a reason rather than replacing the negated fact, so denn is correct, not sondern.
Common mistakes
Ich bin müde aber ich arbeite weiter.→ Ich bin müde, aber ich arbeite weiter.. aber always takes a comma before it when it connects two main clauses.Er ist nicht müde, aber hungrig.→ Er ist nicht müde, sondern hungrig.. The first clause is negated and the second clause replaces it with the true state, so sondern is required, not aber.Ich mag Tee, sondern ich trinke lieber Kaffee.→ Ich mag Tee, aber ich trinke lieber Kaffee.. The first clause is not negated, so sondern cannot be used; a simple contrast with aber is correct here.Wir bleiben zu Hause, denn es heute regnet.→ Wir bleiben zu Hause, denn es regnet heute.. denn is a coordinating conjunction, so the clause after it keeps normal verb-second word order, unlike the subordinating weil, which would send the verb to the end.Ich kaufe Brot, und Milch.→ Ich kaufe Brot und Milch.. und here connects only two words, not two full main clauses, so no comma is used before it.
Remember
- The five coordinating conjunctions are und, aber, oder, denn, and sondern; none of them change the word order of the clauses they connect.
- A comma is always required before aber, denn, and sondern; it is optional before und and oder when joining two main clauses, and never used when und/oder join only two words.
- Sondern can only follow a negated clause, and the second clause must replace the negated fact; aber can follow anything and simply adds a contrast.
- Denn behaves like a coordinating conjunction (verb stays second), unlike the subordinating weil, which sends the verb to the end.
- A shared subject can be dropped from the second clause only when it would otherwise be the first word of that clause.