Relative Clauses, Part 2 (Relativsätze, Teil 2)
CEFR level B1 · Chapter 76 · 80 exercises · about 30 minutes
Form and use the dative relative pronouns (dem, der, dem, denen) and the genitive relative pronouns (dessen, deren — used without a following article), attach relative pronouns to prepositions in whatever case each preposition governs, use wo as a spoken-register alternative for places and time, and combine two sentences into complex dative, genitive, or prepositional relative clauses with correct comma placement.
Practise Relative Clauses, Part 2
Part 1 (Chapter 75) covered relative clauses whose pronoun is the subject or direct object of its own clause — the nominative and accusative forms der/die/das/die and den/die/das/die. This chapter, Part 2, completes the relative pronoun system by adding the two remaining cases: the dative, used for indirect objects and for verbs that always take the dative (helfen, danken, gefallen, vertrauen...), and the genitive, which works like an embedded "whose" and shows possession inside the relative clause.
Alongside the case system, this chapter also covers what happens when the shared element is not a direct or indirect object but the object of a preposition — der Mann, mit dem ich spreche — and a common, informal shortcut for places (and sometimes time) that many learners meet in everyday spoken German before they meet it in a textbook: wo, used instead of a preposition and a case-marked pronoun.
None of this changes the fundamentals you already know from Part 1: a relative pronoun still takes its gender and number from its antecedent (the noun it refers back to), its clause is still set off by commas, and its finite verb still moves all the way to the end. What is new is simply a wider range of pronoun forms and preposition combinations to choose from, based on the pronoun's grammatical job inside its own clause.
Recap: the pronoun's case depends on its job in the relative clause
The single most important rule from Part 1 still governs everything in Part 2: the relative pronoun agrees in gender and number with its antecedent, but its case comes entirely from the role it plays inside its own clause — never from the case of the antecedent back in the main clause.
So far you have only needed this rule to choose between nominative and accusative. Now the same logic extends to the dative (an indirect object, or the object of a dative-only verb), the genitive (a possessive relationship), and any case a preposition happens to require. The clause itself still sends its finite verb to the very end, exactly as before.
The dative relative pronouns: dem, der, dem, denen
Use the dative relative pronoun when the shared noun functions as an indirect object in its own clause, or follows a verb that always takes the dative — helfen, danken, gefallen, vertrauen, glauben, gratulieren, and others. The forms are dem (masculine), der (feminine), dem (neuter), and denen (plural).
Notice that the singular forms are identical to the dative definite articles you already know; only the plural form, denen, is new — it replaces the dative plural article den (den Kindern), so it is easy to confuse the two if you are not paying attention.
Der Mann, dem ich geholfen habe, ist mein Nachbar. (helfen takes the dative; Mann is masculine, so dem.) Die Kinder, denen ich geholfen habe, sind meine Nichten. (plural, so denen, not den.)
The genitive relative pronouns: dessen and deren
The genitive relative pronoun expresses "whose": dessen for masculine and neuter antecedents, deren for feminine and plural antecedents. Unlike every other relative pronoun, dessen and deren behave grammatically like possessive articles (mein, sein, ihr) rather than like the definite article — and that has one crucial consequence: no article ever follows dessen or deren. The noun comes directly after, exactly as it would after mein or sein.
Der Mann, dessen Auto kaputt ist, wartet auf den Abschleppwagen. Die Frau, deren Sohn hier studiert, kommt aus Spanien. Die Leute, deren Haus wir besucht haben, sind sehr gastfreundlich.
The choice between dessen and deren depends only on the antecedent — the noun before the comma — never on the noun that follows. Das Kind, dessen Eltern im Ausland leben, wohnt bei den Großeltern: Kind is neuter singular, so dessen is correct even though the following noun, Eltern, is plural.
Relative pronouns after a preposition
When the shared element is the object of a preposition inside the relative clause, the preposition moves to the front of the clause together with the relative pronoun, and the pronoun takes whatever case that preposition always governs — exactly as it would with any ordinary noun phrase.
Die Frau, mit der ich spreche, ist meine Chefin. (mit always takes the dative, so the feminine pronoun is der.) Der Stift, mit dem ich schreibe, ist blau. (mit + dative, Stift is masculine, so dem.) Die Firma, für die ich arbeite, ist bekannt. (für always takes the accusative, so die.)
With two-way prepositions (in, an, auf, über, unter, vor, hinter, neben, zwischen), decide accusative or dative the same way you would in a main clause: a fixed location (wo?) takes the dative, movement toward a destination (wohin?) takes the accusative. Das Haus, in dem ich wohne, ist sehr alt. (a fixed location, so dative.)
wo instead of preposition + relative pronoun for places (and sometimes time)
For places, spoken German very often replaces preposition + relative pronoun with the short, invariable word wo: die Stadt, wo ich wohne means the same as die Stadt, in der ich wohne. wo never changes for gender, number, or case, which makes it a convenient shortcut — but it is informal, and it only works when the antecedent is, or behaves like, a place.
wo is also sometimes extended to time expressions in casual speech: Das war die Zeit, wo wir noch jung waren. (More formally: ..., als wir noch jung waren, or ..., in der wir noch jung waren.)
In careful writing, prefer the case-marked preposition + relative pronoun (in der, in dem, aus dem...) over wo, and never use wo for a person or for an abstract noun such as der Grund or die Tatsache — those always need a proper, case-marked relative pronoun.
Punctuation and combining more complex sentences
Every relative clause is still set off by commas on both sides (or by a comma and the end of the sentence), exactly as in Part 1 — regardless of which case the relative pronoun takes or whether a preposition precedes it.
To combine two sentences into one using a dative, genitive, or prepositional relative clause: find the noun the two sentences share, delete it (and its article) from the second sentence, replace it with the correct relative pronoun in the case its role in that second clause requires, move that pronoun — together with any preposition — to the front of the clause, and send that clause's finite verb to the end.
Ich kenne den Mann. + Ich habe dem Mann das Buch gegeben. → Ich kenne den Mann, dem ich das Buch gegeben habe.
| Gender/Number | Nominative | Accusative | Dative | Genitive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| masculine | der | den | dem | dessen |
| feminine | die | die | der | deren |
| neuter | das | das | dem | dessen |
| plural | die | die | denen | deren |
The nominative and accusative columns match Part 1; this chapter focuses on the dative and genitive columns, where denen (not den) and dessen/deren (not des/der) are the forms to learn.
| Preposition | Case it governs | Example | English |
|---|---|---|---|
| mit (always dative) | dative | der Stift, mit dem ich schreibe | the pen I write with |
| für (always accusative) | accusative | die Frau, für die ich arbeite | the woman I work for |
| von (always dative) | dative | die Kollegin, von der ich erzählt habe | the colleague I told you about |
| ohne (always accusative) | accusative | der Freund, ohne den ich nicht fahre | the friend without whom I don't go |
| in (two-way, here location) | dative | das Haus, in dem ich wohne | the house I live in |
| auf (two-way, here direction) | accusative | die Party, auf die ich mich freue | the party I am looking forward to |
The preposition always keeps its own fixed case (mit/von = dative, für/ohne = accusative) or follows the usual two-way logic for in/an/auf/...; the relative pronoun simply takes whatever case results.
Examples
- Der Mann, dem ich geholfen habe, ist mein Nachbar. — The man I helped is my neighbor. helfen takes the dative; Mann is masculine, so the relative pronoun is dem.
- Die Kinder, denen ich geholfen habe, sind meine Nichten. — The children I helped are my nieces. The plural dative relative pronoun is denen, not den, which would be accusative singular masculine.
- Der Mann, dessen Auto kaputt ist, wartet auf den Abschleppwagen. — The man whose car is broken is waiting for the tow truck. dessen behaves like a possessive article and is followed directly by the noun, with no article.
- Die Frau, deren Sohn hier studiert, kommt aus Spanien. — The woman whose son studies here is from Spain. deren is used for feminine and plural antecedents; again, no article follows it.
- Die Leute, deren Haus wir besucht haben, sind sehr gastfreundlich. — The people whose house we visited are very hospitable. deren also covers plural antecedents like die Leute.
- Der Stift, mit dem ich schreibe, ist blau. — The pen I am writing with is blue. mit always governs the dative, so the masculine relative pronoun after it is dem.
- Die Frau, für die ich arbeite, ist sehr nett. — The woman I work for is very nice. für always governs the accusative, so the feminine relative pronoun after it is die.
- Die Kollegin, von der ich erzählt habe, kommt morgen. — The colleague I told you about is coming tomorrow. von always governs the dative, so the feminine relative pronoun after it is der.
- Die Stadt, wo ich wohne, ist sehr schön. — The city where I live is very beautiful. wo can replace in der for a place, especially in spoken German.
- Das war die Zeit, wo wir noch jung waren. — That was the time when we were still young. wo is also used informally for time expressions, though als or in der is preferred in careful writing.
Common mistakes
Der Mann, dessen das Auto kaputt ist, wartet auf die Werkstatt.→ Der Mann, dessen Auto kaputt ist, wartet auf die Werkstatt.. dessen and deren function like possessive articles, so no article ever follows them — dessen Auto, not dessen das Auto.Die Frau, mit die ich spreche, ist meine Chefin.→ Die Frau, mit der ich spreche, ist meine Chefin.. mit always governs the dative, so the feminine relative pronoun after it must be der, not die, which is nominative/accusative.Die Kinder, den ich geholfen habe, haben sich bedankt.→ Die Kinder, denen ich geholfen habe, haben sich bedankt.. helfen takes the dative, and the plural dative relative pronoun is denen, not den, which is accusative singular masculine.Der Grund, wo ich nicht kommen konnte, war das Wetter.→ Der Grund, aus dem ich nicht kommen konnte, war das Wetter.. wo is reserved for places (and informally time); an abstract noun like der Grund needs a case-marked relative pronoun with the right preposition, especially in written German.
Remember
- Dative relative pronouns: dem (masc.), der (fem.), dem (neut.), denen (plural) — only denen differs from the dative articles you already know.
- Genitive relative pronouns: dessen (masc./neut.), deren (fem./plural) — they work like possessives, so no article ever follows them: dessen Auto, deren Haus.
- After a preposition, the relative pronoun takes whatever case that preposition always governs (mit/von + dative, für/ohne + accusative), or the usual two-way logic for in/an/auf/... .
- wo can replace preposition + relative pronoun for places, and informally for time, especially in spoken German — but not for people or abstract nouns.
- A relative pronoun's gender and number always match its antecedent; its case always comes from its job inside its own clause.
- A relative clause is always set off by commas, and its finite verb always goes to the end, no matter which case or preposition is involved.