Relative Clauses, Part 1 (Relativsätze, Teil 1)
CEFR level B1 · Chapter 75 · 93 exercises · about 30 minutes
Choose the correct nominative or accusative relative pronoun (der, die, das, plural die, and accusative masculine den) by matching its gender and number to the antecedent while determining its case from its own role inside the relative clause, place the finite verb at the end of the relative clause, and punctuate the clause correctly with commas.
Practise Relative Clauses, Part 1
A relative clause adds extra information about a noun by attaching a subordinate clause directly after it: Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Nachbar (The man who is standing there is my neighbor). The word that opens this clause, der, is a relative pronoun, and choosing the right one always means answering two completely separate questions.
The first question is about gender and number: which noun does the pronoun refer back to — its antecedent — and is that noun masculine, feminine, neuter, or plural? The second question is about case: what job does the pronoun itself do inside its own relative clause — is it the subject, or is it the direct object of the clause's verb? These two questions have two independent answers. Gender and number always come from the antecedent; case always comes from the pronoun's own role inside the relative clause, no matter what case the antecedent happens to have back in the main clause.
This chapter covers only the nominative and accusative relative pronouns — the forms needed when the pronoun is the subject or the direct object of the relative clause. In these two cases, the relative pronoun is identical to the definite article you already know: der, die, das, die for the subject (nominative), and den, die, das, die for the direct object (accusative). Only the masculine singular changes its shape (der becomes den); feminine, neuter, and plural look the same in both cases, so telling them apart means checking what the pronoun actually does in its clause, not just what it looks like.
Two independent questions: gender/number and case
Every relative pronoun answers two separate questions, and keeping them apart is the key skill of this chapter. First: what gender and number does the pronoun have? That is decided entirely by the antecedent — the noun immediately before the relative clause that the pronoun refers back to. Second: what case does the pronoun have? That is decided entirely by the pronoun's own grammatical role inside the relative clause itself.
These two decisions never influence each other. The antecedent can be in any case in the main clause (subject, object, whatever) — that case is irrelevant to the relative pronoun. Look at the antecedent only to find gender and number; then look inside the relative clause and ask "what job does the pronoun do here?" to find the case.
Nominative and accusative relative pronouns match the definite article
In the nominative and accusative, German relative pronouns are identical to the forms of the definite article der/die/das that you already know: der (masculine, nominative), den (masculine, accusative), die (feminine, both), das (neuter, both), and die (plural, both).
This makes the forms easy to remember, but it also means you cannot simply "read off" the case from the outside for feminine, neuter, or plural antecedents — die and das each cover two different cases, so only the pronoun's function inside its clause tells you which one is meant.
The nominative relative pronoun: subject of the relative clause
Use the nominative relative pronoun (der, die, das, die) when the pronoun is the subject of the verb inside the relative clause — the one performing the action described there.
Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Nachbar. Inside the clause der dort steht, der is the one who steht (stands), so it is nominative, matching masculine singular Mann.
The accusative relative pronoun: direct object of the relative clause
Use the accusative relative pronoun (den, die, das, die) when the pronoun is the direct object of the verb inside the relative clause — the thing or person the action is done to.
Der Film, den wir gestern gesehen haben, war spannend. Inside the clause den wir gestern gesehen haben, den is what wir gesehen haben (we watched), so it is accusative — even though Film itself is masculine and would normally suggest der. Only the masculine form visibly changes (der → den); feminine die, neuter das, and plural die keep the same shape as their nominative twins.
Verb-final word order inside the relative clause
A relative clause is a subordinate clause, just like the weil-, wenn-, and dass-clauses from Chapter 46. That means the finite (conjugated) verb moves all the way to the end of the relative clause, after the relative pronoun, subject, objects, and adverbs.
Die Frau, die in Berlin wohnt, ist meine Tante. The verb wohnt sits at the very end of die in Berlin wohnt, not in second position as it would in a main clause (Sie wohnt in Berlin).
Comma rules: the relative clause is always set off by commas
A relative clause is always separated from the rest of the sentence by a comma — this is never optional in German, unlike in English. If the relative clause sits in the middle of the sentence (because more of the main clause follows it), it needs a comma both before and after it.
Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Nachbar. — one comma opens the relative clause right after Mann, and a second comma closes it right after steht, before the main clause continues with ist mein Nachbar. If the relative clause is the last part of the sentence, only the opening comma is needed, and the sentence ends with a full stop: Ich habe einen Freund, der in München lebt.
| Gender / Number | Nominative (subject) | Accusative (direct object) |
|---|---|---|
| masculine | der | den |
| feminine | die | die |
| neuter | das | das |
| plural (all genders) | die | die |
Only the masculine singular changes shape between the two cases; feminine, neuter, and plural forms are identical in both, so the pronoun's role inside its own clause is what tells them apart.
| Antecedent (its case in the main clause) | Relative clause | Relative pronoun and its case |
|---|---|---|
| der Mann (nominative — subject of ist) | der dort steht | der — nominative (subject of steht) |
| einen Freund (accusative — object of habe) | der in München lebt | der — nominative (subject of lebt) |
| der Film (nominative — subject of war) | den wir gesehen haben | den — accusative (object of gesehen haben) |
| die Kollegin (accusative — object of kenne) | die aus Spanien kommt | die — nominative (subject of kommt) |
Compare rows 1 and 3, or rows 2 and 4: the same antecedent case in the main clause can pair with either a nominative or an accusative relative pronoun — the pronoun's case depends only on its own job inside its own clause, never on the antecedent's case.
Examples
- Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Nachbar. — The man who is standing there is my neighbor. Der Mann is masculine singular, and der is the subject of steht inside the clause, so it is nominative.
- Die Frau, die neben mir sitzt, kommt aus Spanien. — The woman who is sitting next to me comes from Spain. Die Frau is feminine singular; die is the subject of sitzt, so it is nominative.
- Das Kind, das im Garten spielt, heißt Lena. — The child who is playing in the garden is called Lena. Das Kind is neuter singular; das is the subject of spielt, so it is nominative.
- Die Bücher, die auf dem Tisch liegen, gehören mir. — The books that are lying on the table belong to me. Die Bücher is plural; die is the subject of liegen, so it is nominative — the plural relative pronoun is die for every gender.
- Der Film, den wir gestern gesehen haben, war spannend. — The film that we watched yesterday was exciting. Der Film is masculine, but inside the clause it is the object of gesehen haben, so the pronoun takes the accusative form den, not der.
- Die Tasche, die ich letzte Woche gekauft habe, ist schon kaputt. — The bag that I bought last week is already broken. Die Tasche is feminine; die is the object of gekauft habe inside the clause (accusative) — feminine accusative looks identical to feminine nominative.
- Das Auto, das mein Bruder fährt, ist neu. — The car that my brother drives is new. Das Auto is neuter; das is the object of fährt (accusative) — neuter accusative also looks identical to neuter nominative.
- Die Studenten, die die Prüfung bestanden haben, feiern heute Abend. — The students who passed the exam are celebrating tonight. Die Studenten is plural; the first die is the relative pronoun (subject of bestanden haben, nominative), and the second die is simply the article of Prüfung.
- Ich habe einen Freund, der in München lebt. — I have a friend who lives in Munich. Freund is masculine; der is the subject of lebt inside the relative clause, so it is nominative, even though Freund is accusative (object of habe) in the main clause.
- Das ist die Kollegin, die ich gestern im Meeting kennengelernt habe. — That is the colleague whom I met in the meeting yesterday. Kollegin is feminine; die is the object of kennengelernt habe inside the clause (accusative), which happens to look the same as the nominative form.
Common mistakes
Der Film, der wir gestern gesehen haben, war spannend.→ Der Film, den wir gestern gesehen haben, war spannend.. Film is the direct object of gesehen haben inside the relative clause, so the pronoun must be accusative den — the pronoun's case depends on its job inside its own clause, not on the antecedent.Ich habe einen Freund, den in München lebt.→ Ich habe einen Freund, der in München lebt.. Even though Freund is accusative in the main clause (object of habe), the pronoun is the subject of lebt inside the relative clause, so it must be nominative der.Der Mann der dort steht ist mein Nachbar.→ Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Nachbar.. A relative clause is always set off by commas — one before it starts and one after it ends, even when it sits in the middle of the sentence.Die Frau, die wohnt in Berlin, ist meine Tante.→ Die Frau, die in Berlin wohnt, ist meine Tante.. The relative clause is a subordinate clause, so its finite verb (wohnt) must move to the very end of the clause, not stay in second position.
Remember
- Gender and number of the relative pronoun come from the antecedent — the noun it refers back to.
- Case of the relative pronoun comes only from its own role inside the relative clause — subject or direct object — never from the antecedent's case in the main clause.
- In the nominative and accusative, relative pronouns are identical to the definite article: der, die, das, die (nominative) and den, die, das, die (accusative).
- Only the masculine singular changes shape between nominative (der) and accusative (den); feminine, neuter, and plural look the same in both, so check the pronoun's function to know its case.
- The finite verb of the relative clause moves to the very end, just like in weil/wenn/dass clauses.
- A relative clause is always framed by commas — one before it and, if it doesn't end the sentence, one right after it.